"How shall the young become acquainted with the past in such a way that the acquaintance is a potent agent in appreciation of the living present?"
John Dewey
1938
John Dewey, the American philosopher, psychologist and educational reformer wrote a book - 'Experience and Education.' How apt!
Here is a review of it by someone on the internet. Tomorrow, I'll check the library for it.
An Examination of John Deweys Experience and Education
(how I would've liked to chat with him)
Showing posts with label quote. Show all posts
Showing posts with label quote. Show all posts
Monday, August 16, 2010
Wednesday, August 4, 2010
"Every view of the world that becomes extinct, every culture that disappears, diminishes a possibility of life."
Mexican writer and poet, winner of the 1990 Nobel Proze for Literature
Tuesday, July 27, 2010
"The struggle of man against power is the struggle of memory against forgetting"
Milan Kundera
Milan Kundera
Monday, July 19, 2010
Reading: Dmitri Nikulin: Memory and History
No one ever remembers alone – Ricoeur.
History is a multi layered enterprise. It does not rely on one universal history; instead it embraces a variety of histories. At a micro level – personal memory is private and internal. But as Halbwach says personal history is inscribed into a collective memory. Personal memory feels the need to understand itself within the framework of a more external, in this case, collective memory. Obviously then, collective memory remains broken, relying on oral transmissions and rituals remaining within a group. Historical memory, the macro; picks up these pieces, by drawing this unified picture of the past. This tends to translate into a one-sided, filtered, historian’s view of history. I agree when Nikulin says we must substitute the one unified, yet no one’s history with a whole plurality of fragmented histories. Purists would probably cringe – the thought of having a chaotic, emotional and multi sided view. Isn’t it better having a single integrated one – that doesn’t lend itself to a spectrum of interpretation? Last week’s reading tackled the topic of who decides what is considered as history. This ‘single integrated one’ is only going to be a reflection of what these decision makers believe we need to know. When living in today’s present we are bombarded with a variety of opinions and ‘memories’ by the media and people in authority, and we are left with interpreting it as we like, then why can’t we treat history as being a present, only a few years ago.
Another interesting point was Nikulin’s comparison between memory and imagination. Both are never concerned about the ‘is’. One is about things that have happened, the other is about things that could – that being a distance from the perceived and the thought.
Memory is alive.
Memory, as something in your mind is always prone to change – by forgetting and fabricating. By wanting to believe something, your memory slowly rewrites itself and by wanting to let go of certain details, your memory erases itself. This ensures that memory is never boring and remains novel. Self-interpretation is a constant process of evaluating your memories.
Nikulin also discusses an imageless history versus a nameless one. An image is more open to interpretation than a name. An image needs a narrative – it is external and secondary to the narrative. An image only assists in showing what the name intends to tell. The priority of history is to be told, and not shown.
History is a multi layered enterprise. It does not rely on one universal history; instead it embraces a variety of histories. At a micro level – personal memory is private and internal. But as Halbwach says personal history is inscribed into a collective memory. Personal memory feels the need to understand itself within the framework of a more external, in this case, collective memory. Obviously then, collective memory remains broken, relying on oral transmissions and rituals remaining within a group. Historical memory, the macro; picks up these pieces, by drawing this unified picture of the past. This tends to translate into a one-sided, filtered, historian’s view of history. I agree when Nikulin says we must substitute the one unified, yet no one’s history with a whole plurality of fragmented histories. Purists would probably cringe – the thought of having a chaotic, emotional and multi sided view. Isn’t it better having a single integrated one – that doesn’t lend itself to a spectrum of interpretation? Last week’s reading tackled the topic of who decides what is considered as history. This ‘single integrated one’ is only going to be a reflection of what these decision makers believe we need to know. When living in today’s present we are bombarded with a variety of opinions and ‘memories’ by the media and people in authority, and we are left with interpreting it as we like, then why can’t we treat history as being a present, only a few years ago.
Another interesting point was Nikulin’s comparison between memory and imagination. Both are never concerned about the ‘is’. One is about things that have happened, the other is about things that could – that being a distance from the perceived and the thought.
Memory is alive.
Memory, as something in your mind is always prone to change – by forgetting and fabricating. By wanting to believe something, your memory slowly rewrites itself and by wanting to let go of certain details, your memory erases itself. This ensures that memory is never boring and remains novel. Self-interpretation is a constant process of evaluating your memories.
Nikulin also discusses an imageless history versus a nameless one. An image is more open to interpretation than a name. An image needs a narrative – it is external and secondary to the narrative. An image only assists in showing what the name intends to tell. The priority of history is to be told, and not shown.
Clifford, 1988
"Is not every ethnographer something of a surrealist, a reinventor and reshuffler of realities?"
James Clifford, The Predicament of Culture
James Clifford, The Predicament of Culture
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
